Hello dear
Welcome to Shelly's Corned Beef
Shelly's Corned Beef, located at 4300 W Elm St, McHenry, IL, has quickly become a local favorite for its exceptional Reuben sandwiches. Known for its generous portions and perfectly balanced flavors, this charming eatery offers a delightful escape from corporate chains. Customers rave about the attentive staff and inviting atmosphere, which makes every visit feel special. The fresh ingredients and meticulous presentation, highlighted by their signature sandwiches carefully wrapped with sides, reflect their commitment to quality. From complimentary cookies to a clean environment, Shelly's proves to be a hidden gem worth frequent visits for any sandwich lover.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Beef Hot Dog
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Corned Beef Sandwich
Reuben
About
Shelly's Corned Beef
Welcome to Shelly's Corned Beef, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of McHenry, Illinois. Located at 4300 W Elm St, this establishment is where hearty flavors and exceptional service meet. Recognized for its delectable sandwiches, particularly their renowned Reuben, Shelly's has captured the hearts—and appetites—of many local food lovers.
What makes Shelly's stand out is not just the quality of their food but the passion evident in every bite. Customers rave about the Reuben, describing it as "the best in the area." This hype is well-deserved; the sandwich is generously piled high with perfectly seasoned corned beef, grilled to a flawless crispness, and balanced with just the right toppings. Danielle Salemi shares her daily cravings, stating how the flavors are "on point," highlighting the care that goes into crafting each meal.
Yet, it’s more than just the food that keeps customers returning. Shelly's offers a warm, inviting atmosphere, where staff members are not just efficient but genuinely friendly. As Haley Blain noted, upon visiting Shelly's for her pregnancy craving, she was welcomed by a clean space and attentive service, complete with a complimentary cookie—a personal touch that showcases their commitment to customer satisfaction. Such gestures elevate the dining experience from simply eating out to feeling welcomed and valued.
Whether you're a local or just visiting, Shelly's Corned Beef is a promising stop for anyone seeking comfort food with a homestyle twist. With quick service and memorable meals, it's no wonder that diners like Donna Maksuti are willing to drive from the city just for a taste of that Reuben. The establishment has truly carved out its niche, allowing it to shine amidst larger corporate eateries, fully embracing its identity as an exceptional local favorite.
In a world full of dining options, Shelly's Corned Beef perfectly embodies what it means to find satisfaction in a simple meal. Don’t hesitate; grab your friends or family and discover what all the buzz is about. You just might find your new favorite sandwich!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Come here almost on a daily basis for the Ruben bc it is so good. They pile the meat high and the flavors are on point. Best Ruben in the area. So happy they opened and the staff is quick, friendly, and So efficient. ”
“ I Drive From The City To Go To Shelly's For Their Reuben .yes sometimes the service is kinda laxxed but they are far from rude and sandwiches are on point. It sometimes nice to get away from the big corporate eateries and just find that hidden gem ”
“ We recently moved to the area and pass Shelly’s everyday when we’re coming and going and have always wanted to try it. My pregnancy craving led us there today for a Reuben and we were immediately struck by how clean & nice the restaurant is, and greeted by a really friendly staff member who took our order with care and made our food to-go for us. She even gave us each a free cookie as we left! We came home to eat it and found our sandwiches carefully wrapped, in individual boxes with pickles and our choice of chips. The Reuben itself was a 10/10! Clearly panini pressed, perfect propotions/ratios and totally satisfied the craving in a day where I couldn’t bring myself to eat anything else all day. Thank you, Shelly’s! We will be back! ”
“ My son and I came in for a quick bite and split their Dynamic Duo. It was delicious! Tastes fresh and service was quick. The man working also threw in a few cookies for us that were just as tasty! Recommend and will be back! ”